AIS Guesbook
  Join the conversation by letting us know what’s on your mind.

Add Guestbook Entry

Anti-spam measures
Please insert the letter and number combination into the text field before submitting the guestbook entry.

Total Entries: 125
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Mohan and Padmini Hingorani - USA 
Thu, 1 January 1970 00:00:00 +0000

Our gratitude to you for sending us two additional themes , namely, Theme Five- The story of Saraswati River,Theme six- The Story of Soma wine,

We are most grateful to you for your kindness and shall look forward to receiving more themes from you at your kind convenience.

These themes, along with earlier themes that you kindly sent to us have the true hall mark of excellence and the manner in which you have presented all these themes is praiseworthy.

There have been thousands of books and hundreds of thousands essays and commentries on Bharat Varshe from the Vedic and post Vedic periods after the great Vedas wrer composed. BUT not a single essay or article or book has been written by our great people on the pre Vedic period ie. the period before the RIG Veda and other vedas came to be written. Why? Because it is so easy to write brilliant books and essays of Vedic period as already much has been written during that time by learned philosophers. Fortunately your writer Mr Gidwani went far backwards to dig deep into the earlier roots of our vedic civilization and produced the book on our pre Vedic past when the earlist roots of Hinduism were formed in the shape of Sanatan Dharma. Now your themes are based on that book and presented in a very logical manner but since there is no other book of those pre-history times, is there any real scope for comments by any of us. In view of this, we would sumarize our comments as follows:

You are doing a true public service by circulating these fine research themes. Please continue this fine program. To discontinue it would be a pity. These themes extend the frontiers of our knowledge
At the same time you must encourage Universities to study these themes and come up with additional or supplementary material. In fact the attempt should be to encurage writers to research pre Vedic times to write more booke and essays on that period of prehistory. Please do not misunderstand this as a criticism of Mr Gidwani s work as we are convinced that he has done a remarkable job but let us face it., that period is so great that there is scope for hundreds of researched books instead of just one single book by Mr Gidwani though undoubtedly it is a magnificent book.
Similarly, you must try to interest not only Universities but also Government of India to sponsor a study of pre-Vedic era to add to material unearthed by your writer Mr Gidwani. How can such a period which forms the very foundation of our civilizations and Sanatana Dharma be the subject matter of one single book by your writer when obviously there is scope for a much wider coverage
Having said that, we would like to compliment AIS for presenting these great Themes brilliantly as there is real need for these Themes and it is essential for you to continue them without fail.

Mohan Hingorani
Padmani Hingorani
11 19 2007

Reply: Thank you for your comments.
Bulo and Gita Thawani - USA 
Thu, 1 January 1970 00:00:00 +0000

Dear and Respected Dr Dial Gidwani and Directors Office Bearers Members of AIS,

Our thanks for sending us firstly your four marvellous Themes and now these two excellent themes:Five and Six-
You have asked for individual feed-back and comments. I do not know what to say to you in response. You have done such an excellent job in such elegant manner that all I can say is : Thank you, Ladies and Gentlemen of AIS, for a job well done with a sense of dedication and a will to expand our knowledge in a commendable manner. . I thank you and I am certain that those who see these themes, will thank you for advancing their knowledge of these on the subjects. THANK YOU
As to your question: if this program of presenting these themes should be continued or in any way modified: My answer is simple: To discontinue or limit this program would be a tragedy.

Once again, my thanks

With Sincere Regards and Appreciation

Bulo and Gita Thanwani 11 19 2007

Reply: Thank you for your comments.
Indrarani Bhatia - USA 
Thu, 1 January 1970 00:00:00 +0000

I have to thank you for the understanding and enlightenment that I received from your Theme “OM OM OM! First Word of God?

At the same time I wondered why it is that we Hindus are so ignorant about the basic fundamentals of our faith and culture when Christians know so much about their faith; and Muslims too know all about their Islamic tenets; and similarly the Jews. Even Buddhists, Jains, Sikhs, which are the off shoots of Hinduism know so much about the basics of their faith and culture while we Hindus are so ignorant and unaware.

But then I thought that the ignorance was personally mine and that other Hindus may know better. I checked it out on last four Sundays from groups who visit the same temple as I do practically every Sunday when lunch is also served. I found that these educated Hindus while they utter OM and Om Shanti Shanti often, they know so little about the significance, inspiration ad even the history of OM. Their ignorance was as much as mine was before I read your Theme. I hope you succeed in breaking this barrier of ignorance among Hindus.

Please do not think I am a fanatic. Like every enlightened hindu I respect and honor all faiths but I just do not see why everyone including even Hindus treats Hinduism the way they do. Hence my respect for Sindhulogy for giving Hinduism its due and bringing out glory of Sanatan Dharma - our ageless faith

We Hindus have reason to be ashamed of ourselves and sorry for being such poor examples to our children and grand children.
. So I see your work by Sindhulogy with respect

What I say about your Theme on OM, is true of other themes too. These three other Themes that you have presented also bring lot of enlightenment It is to be hoped that their message reaches all and your members have duty to see that they re- circulate these themes reach as many people as possible. Themes have educational value for 3 4 generation, for book clubs

My grateful thanks to Sindhulogy Institute and its officers workers members for its extraordinary work.

Indrani Bhatia

Reply: Thank you for your comments.
Jayesh Methwani - New York 
Thu, 1 January 1970 00:00:00 +0000

Greetings and Happy Diwali. Mr. Gidwani.

Thank you for taking the time to speak to me this afternoon, very kind of you to share your organizations goal, which I sincerely appreciate as a born Sindhi from India.

As per our conversation, I am sending this email and look forward to working with you. Please feel free to ring me at anytime, Im just a phone call away.


Jayesh Methwani

Reply: Dear Jayesh, Thank you for your call. I am very happy to recognize your interest in our Ancient Culture. AIS is happy to welcome our 3/4 generation to
Prannath Jaidev - USA 
Thu, 1 January 1970 00:00:00 +0000

Truly, you deserve congratulations of highest order for presenting the following four theme:


Chapter 2 - Concern for Environment in Bharat Varsha in Pre-Vedic times - 8000 BCE

Chapter 3 - Woman s Status In Ancient Bharat Varsha the Indian Subcontinent

Chapter 4 - Aryans In Germany 5000 BCE

You have presented these themes in a very admirable style so that even a novice can understand these complex subjects and admire the clear message that springs from them.

I thank Sindhulogy Institute for this great service.

I have read bhagwan gidwani s outstanding book Return of the aryans. BUT i am satisfied that the way you have presented these themes is superior even to Bhagwan gidwani s presentation. I am not finding fault with bhagwan gidwani for he has done great service but he was trying to tell a great story of Sanatan Dharma and Hinduism, and within that story was giving outstanding knowledge of these intricate and important subjects. In separating these themes from the story, you have done a truly great job and your manner of presenting these is really highly appealing.

PranNath Jaidev


Reply: Thank you for your gracious encouraging comments 11/14/2007
Bhowmick Narayan - California 
Thu, 1 January 1970 00:00:00 +0000

What a pleasure it is to visit the AIS website. I have learnt much from it - and I shall keep visiting it often.

The site was recommended to me by my friend S.N. Kaul but I did not expect the site to be as great as Kaul recommended it. It is truly superb. What fascinates me are the themes from Return of the Aryans . I loved the theme on OM, Om Om - the first word of God. Also three other themes are truly great - each a masterpiece.

Thank you AIS, keep those themes coming. There is real literature, knowledge and wisdom in these great themes.
AIS fills admirably the sad cultural vacuum left in our times


Reply: Thank you for your words of encouragement.W will be mailing two more themes Saraswati river and Soma wine 11/12/2007
Bulo Gita Thanwani - Detroit 
Thu, 1 January 1970 00:00:00 +0000

Thank you sir for your message Re: Song of Sindhu Hindu now available on AIS web site for listening- Down loading.

It is a real pleasue To listen to Song of Sindhu Hindu available on AIS web site.



Reply: Thank you for your comments.
Putli Arjun Dadlani - london 
Thu, 1 January 1970 00:00:00 +0000

Sindhulogy deserves to be congratulated for this remarkable effort of presenting FIFTY THREE THEMES FROM Return of the Aryans FOR EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH

Putli and I have read with pleasure your fine summaries of Research on :

Theme one - OM OM OM! First word of God?
Theme two- Environment in Bharat Varsha in Pre-Vedic times - 8000 BCE.
The fourth theme - Aryans in Germany in from Bharata Varsha 5,000 BCE.

Truly, we are impressed. You have put in effort in clarifying the issues on which more research needs to be done.

I have circulated copies of your Email along with these four research papers to quite a few friends and asscoiates and while I have not received feed-back from all of them, the few feedbacks I have received from professors and other academics conclusively prove to me that your action is worthy of follow-up and real research on these subjects will indeed provide a great contribution to historical literature.

I am sure your mailing list is wide and includes also non-Sindhi historians and academics. I would suggest that you send such research papers to all universities and in particular to all those who have India Asia study programs.


Arjun and Putli Dadlani

Reply: Thank you for your comments.
Sital Meghnani - Newyork 
Thu, 1 January 1970 00:00:00 +0000

Dear AIS,

Your papers break out a new and great route for research. I admired all the four research papers and in particular on OM and Germany. But fascinating as they are, the question is : who is to do the research? While Gidwani has done fine work in his great book, Return of Aryans, his book shows that it took him endless years to do his research. Now you want more research. Certainly, it is a laudable objective and one that should be persued. But unless a band of true researchers can be found, there can be little progress.

Even so, I am happy at your presentation. It brings into focus the summary of research so far - leaving a challenge to researchers in the future. Please continue. Thanks.

Sital Menghnani

Reply: Thank you for your comments.
L alit Jhangiani - Chicago IL 
Thu, 1 January 1970 00:00:00 +0000

Dear Mr. Gidwani,

THANK YOU VERY MUCH for taking the time, trouble, and other resources required to produce the Song of Sindhu CD. It is truly inspirational; and I have already circulated copies to friends and family members alike.

Also, thanks for your leadership in making this organization a reality. YOU are a true inspiration to Sindhus of all ages !

Thank You Again,

Lalit Jhangiani

Reply: Thank you for your comments.
Jai Prakash Moorani(Journalist) - Hyderabad 
Thu, 1 January 1970 00:00:00 +0000

Shree Dial Sahib
This was great to visit your website.It was an amazing experience. We in Sindh are very much pleased to see such great efforts to bring allthe Sindhies closer. Here in Sindh there are different news papers providing not only daily news but also the clutural reports and much more about sindh. You can visit our sites as
If any informartion regaring anything in Sindh is required I am here for you.
Now Sindhi software is also available freely why not you make the site in Sindhi also. it will also help our new genration living way from Sindh to keep there Sindhi liguistic knowledge up date.
I am looking forward for your words.
God bless you all

Reply: Thank you for your comments.
sajjan channa - oldham manchester 
Thu, 1 January 1970 00:00:00 +0000

may god help you forever for this nobel work
and give all us sindhi s strenght to recognise our selves and do better for land and language
saj channa

Reply: Thank you Mr. Chana for your encouragement 10/22/07
P. P. HIRANIPhoto-Journalist - 2948 Emerald Chase DriveHerndon, VA-20171 
Thu, 1 January 1970 00:00:00 +0000

Respected Dial Sahib,
You have done a great job and favoured Sindhiyat!
Keep it up. More grease to your shoulders!
I had very hectic holiday of five and half months in
Bombay, with couple of projects. Am back here since
14th August. Hope to see you sometime. God Bless.
Warmest Regards.
2948 Emerald Chase Drive
Herndon, VA-20171.
# 703 956 1968

Reply: Thank you Mr. Hirani 10/21/2007
Engineer Assaram Alamchandani - Karachi Pakistan 
Thu, 1 January 1970 00:00:00 +0000

Dear Founder President Mr Dial Sahib and Mr Hingorani Sahib,
It is me Lord Blessings upon you that you have slected Sindhu name.This name is expressed in our Shastars too it is said that Sindhu is as much Respectable as Ganga and Jmuna for Hindus and all Sindhis as Mother.Mother feed Milk to her Children than Sindhu also feed us much than that from its water we drink,we get agriculture products not for humans but for all God creatures.I realy believe that you are blessed by Sindhu Mata.You need not simple Congratulations but more than that which I pray me Lord to give you more strength to work on this.
I am presently living in Karachi Sindh Pakistan and any information or service you,your team or the Sindhi world over need from me I will be at your Disposal.Further any one from world over want to visit Sindh my doors and arms are open to welcome. Sindhi Hindus have so far no land called as Sindh they should have one.
Sain sadain kareen mathy sindh sukar,
Dost mitha daldar toon alam sabh abad kareen
My Love for you and your family and all Sindhs Global.
Assaram email aac6993 at
Contact # +92 333 390-5052

Reply: Thank you Mr. Alamchandani for your encouraging words.I will write you seperately. Dial V.Gidwani
Roy Mannsukhani - Boston USA 
Thu, 1 January 1970 00:00:00 +0000

First time I had a chance to eview the website and I must complement the designers and developers for a user friendly site. The pioneering work will enable many Sindhi s world wide to appreciate not only their heritage but also the genelogical influence of who we are, why we are and where we are . There is no country I know off that a Sindhi has not found and settled in for one reason or other. This shows we are pioneers and more important leaders.

Who was it that said follow not the path that you see, beat a new path so others may follow.

It may be a good idea to list the names of the persons in alphabetical order who are making a donation without mentioing the amount.

Good Luck and God Bless

Reply: Thank you Roy 6/25/2007
Anil Anita Lalwani - London UK 
Thu, 1 January 1970 00:00:00 +0000

Dear Mr Gidwani

My apologies for this late response.

The new CD on the Song of the Sindhu Hindu is excellent ! It is of high quality, both in content and the sound is clear and melodious! The effort in producing - and distributing -something like this must have been great. My wife, Anita, too has appreciated this very much.

My sincere thanks again, to you, to the musicians and to all others who have helped. I shall keep it alongside my copy of Bhagwan Gidwani s book The Return of the Aryans with great pride, as I am a Sindhu Hindu !

With all good wishes, Anil Lalwani.

Reply: Thank you for your comments 06/10
Ashok and Savita Vazirani - USA 
Thu, 1 January 1970 00:00:00 +0000

Our compliments to Mr. D.M. Butani DMBUTANI at for his magnificent Scroll copied below on the Song of the Sindhu Hindu in which he gives us some great details of Karkarta Bharat, who composed this Song in 5085 BCE along the Banks of Sindhu River and in whose honour the subcontinent came to be known as Bharat Varsha after he retired as a hermit.

Our compliments also to AIS sindhulogy at for producing and distributing to all, the CD to present this great Song with English narration and melodiuos singing in Hindi and Sindhi by Koshi Lalwani and excellent musical accompaniment.

Do kindly circulate to your friends and hopefully, your effort will ensure that Bharat remains alive in our memory.

Ashok and Savita Vazirani 05 18 2007

Reply: Thanks for your comments 05/18/07
Chitra Gidwani Desai - 18, Cimmarron drive Nashua 03062. 
Thu, 1 January 1970 00:00:00 +0000

Dear Dialji,
Thank you for your email.I am very impressed by the website as well as the
work being done by the organization.I will be more than happy to become a
volunteer to help AIS.I reside in Nashua, New hampshire USA.I did listen to
sample songs on the site and was mesmerized by the words,music it was simply
beautiful.Indeed i was and feel all the more proud to be a Sindhi Hindu ,
but foremost we are Indians!


Reply: Thank you Chitra for your offer to volunteer. AIS apprecite.Please read AIS seven year review of perormance,progress and successes. will be posted 05/
kailash k rajesth - nasik india 
Thu, 1 January 1970 00:00:00 +0000

hi i am kailash from nasik india
i have heard the stories of sind from my maternal grand mother and stories of partition i would like to say always be united and respect and love sindhis talk in sindhi
well i am very thankful to all who have made this website and i am feeling proud to be sindhi

kailash rajesth

Reply: Thank you Rajesh. Please infoprm all your friends about AIS's mission and program 04/02/07
Manzoor Ali Kalhoro - Karachi, Sindh 
Thu, 1 January 1970 00:00:00 +0000

hi every one G.A sindh , i am happy after visit this site , i want to inform that sindhi peoples are great and they have great history and culture so we should care of our history and culture i hope every youger involeve in these kind of activities for help of sindh. G.A Sindh.

Reply: Thanbk you Manzoor Saeen We are encouraged by your comments. It is AIS mission to connect mankind through civilization not only of the sub continent b